Refurbished vs new: which phone should you choose?

Updated 15 November 2026 · 5 min read

Short answer

For the same money, a refurbished flagship often gets you more storage and a better camera than a new mid-range phone. A new phone gets you a fresh battery and usually more years of software updates. Before you buy refurbished, check the model is still on the maker's security-update list, the battery, the account lock, the IMEI and the written warranty.

Two friends laughing at a photo on a phone in a mall food court

Choose refurbished if you want a flagship’s camera and storage for mid-range money, and the model is still getting security updates. Choose new if you want a fresh battery, the longest update support and the simplest warranty. Whichever you choose, check the five points below before you pay.

Same money, two phones: a worked example

Takealot cash prices in our catalogue, recorded 14 November 2026:

Refurbished Galaxy S22 New Galaxy A36
Condition Refurbished · very good New
Storage 256 GB 128 GB
Cash price R6 995 R7 199
Samsung security updates (15 Nov 2026) Quarterly Quarterly
Battery Used: check its health New
Phone page Galaxy S22 refurbished Galaxy A36

Here the refurbished flagship gives you double the storage for R204 less, and both are on the same update schedule today. The new phone gives you a battery with no wear.

The check most buyers miss: security updates

A phone that no longer gets security updates is riskier for banking apps and WhatsApp. Samsung publishes which models still get updates on its Security Updates Scope page (security.samsungmobile.com). On 15 November 2026:

Model sold refurbished On Samsung’s list?
Galaxy S23 Yes, monthly
Galaxy S22, S22+, S22 Ultra Yes, quarterly
Galaxy S21 FE 5G Yes, quarterly
Galaxy S21, S21+ Not listed

So a refurbished Galaxy S21 at R6 290 (Takealot, 14 Nov 2026) costs R705 less than the S22, but isn’t on Samsung’s update list. Samsung says the list changes, so check it on the day you buy. For an iPhone, check that the phone can install the latest iOS in Settings → General → Software Update.

What the grades mean

Grade What you see
Like new No visible marks
Very good Light signs of use
Good Visible marks, works perfectly

More detail in refurbished phone grades explained.

Your rights on a refurbished phone

Under sections 55 and 56 of the Consumer Protection Act, goods must be of good quality, in good working order, free of defects, and usable and durable for a reasonable time. Within six months of delivery you can return goods that fall short, and the seller must repair, replace or refund (your choice). If a repair doesn’t fix it within three months, you can ask for a replacement or refund.

The exception: if you were clearly told the phone is in a specific condition and you agreed to take it like that, those quality rights don’t cover that condition. Read the grade description before you pay. Any written warranty from the seller comes on top of these rights.

Checklist before you buy refurbished

  • Security updates: the model is on the maker’s current list
  • Battery health: on iPhone, Settings → Battery → Battery Health
  • Account lock: not linked to someone else’s Apple ID or Google account
  • IMEI: not reported lost or stolen (how to check)
  • Written warranty: how long, what it covers, who repairs it
  • Price: compare with the new phone of the same storage

Buying an iPhone? Use our 8-point refurbished iPhone checklist. Browse refurbished phones, or see how to get a phone with bad credit. YeboCell (ours) offers refurbished and new phones on rent-to-own, with the warranty terms in your written quote.

Sources (checked 15 November 2026)

Questions people ask

Is a refurbished phone worth it?

Often, if the model still gets security updates and the battery is healthy. On 14 November 2026 a refurbished Galaxy S22 256 GB was R6 995 on Takealot and a new Galaxy A36 128 GB was R7 199. Check updates and battery before you decide.

Can I return a faulty refurbished phone?

The Consumer Protection Act lets you return goods that aren't of good quality within six months of delivery, for repair, replacement or a refund. The exception is goods you were clearly told are in a specific condition and agreed to take in that condition, so read the grade description.

How long will a refurbished Samsung get updates?

Check Samsung's Security Updates Scope page. On 15 November 2026 it listed the Galaxy S23 for monthly updates and the S22 for quarterly updates. The S21 and S21+ weren't listed.

Find out what you qualify for.

60 seconds, no payslip needed. Phones from R44/week, 130 to choose from.